Best Magazine
October 1999

Added May 1, 2000

Toriphile Stéphane from France has sent to me an interview/article that appeared in the October 1999 issue of Best Magazine in France. The interview included several very nice full page photos of Tori, a review of the Tori/Alanis show in Charlotte, NC, and a separate interview with Steve Caton. I was able to scan the photos thanks to Stéphane. Tracy Streimish sent me the English translation of most of Tori's interview, and Stuart LaRosa translated the Steve Caton interview for us and the rest of the Tori interview. See all the photos and read the interviews below. The Tori interview is really interesting and I suggest you read it. Tori talks about exploring new directions with the piano, the story of how she wrote 1000 Oceans, talks about her friend Karen Binns (who we saw on VH1 Behind The Music 2), who guides her fashion decisions, how TVAB came about, the net and mp3s and how she feels about them, why she does not sing "Me And A Gun" at every show anymore, and her tour with Alanis and why she always chose to go first. The magazine actually mentions the Dent!

The Photos

Click any of the above to see them at full size

These concert photos os Steve Caton, Tori and Alanis were all likely shot in Charlotte, NC on August 24, 1999

The Interview With Tori

Here is most of the interview translated from French to English. The interview was conducted by Daniel Oliveira.

If a piano could cry, Tori Amos would be its tears.

"I remember I found inspiration while I was walking down streets, not far from here." Tori told those attending the concert at Blockbuster Pavillon in Charlotte, North Carolina on August 24, 1999. Touring across the United States with Alanis Morissette, she shows a certain pride to sing in a town of the state she was born in. Charlotte is at about 90 km from Newton, where this daughter of religious persons saw the light 36 years ago. They were probably far from guessing that their child would one day give concerts in the biggest local venue and that she would become an inspiration for numerous artists of this decade.

Best: You are one of the few artists whose music, constructed mainly around the piano, could conquer the pop and alternative audience. How do you become such an exception?

Tori: A lot of musicians have enough with one style that suits them and don't bring their instruments in exploration of new directions. Despite being a pianist, I mostly studied guitar. If you only study piano music, that can be dangerous for the evolution of your style. You have to approach your instument in a unique way, or you'll only repeat what another one already did. I listen to my drummer, my guitarist and my bassist a lot. I examine relentlessly the way they work and they give me new ideas for the piano. Obviously, I could choose a more conventional approach, but I prefer to venture in unexplored areas. I see myself more as a songwriter than as a singer.

B: Do you have to feel the emotions of your songs in the real life to be able to describe them?

T: [long silence] Sometimes I feel them through other people. Take "1,000 Oceans" on "Venus and Back"; I had a dream at 5 and a half in the morning of an African woman's voice, excessively tribal. It wasn't a language I knew. I only understood the melody and it only had a few measures. I went to my piano, in the dark, and recorded 2 measures on a small tape recorder, which is always on the instrument. I sculpted the song during the following weeks, looking at Mark who just lost his father. Until the day when, striked by what I played in the living room, he said "Could you replay this song about oceans?"

B : Mark... your husband?

T: Yes. There was a moment when I realized I saw different pictures than him about this song. I felt a deep love feeling when he "came in" the song, associating it to the memory and search of his father, because we don't know where those who leave this earth go. Sometimes, the love feelings of my songs come from someone else and I'm just there to look at it.

B : You accept various meanings of your lyrics, but why sometimes make them so hard to understand?

T: I don't think it is so complicated. These are word combinations, but their meaning is not literal. That's what's great at playing with a language. You "go out" with words, you travel, you bathe in language. It's another world.

B: Your videos are always very artistic and you play different roles in them. At what time was the character the closest to your real personality?

T: Some are rather close to what I am at the moment, but there's always a part of them which isn't like me at all. I think the videos are interesting because of the vast choices. I become a prolongation of my songs, in a way. When I shoot a video, it's only partly me. I vanish to let the character's identity come out.

B: Whether it's for videos, concerts or photos, you have many different looks. What's your favorite picture of you?

T: [pause] I don't like to be enclosed in a style, but there's a limit I will never cross. Generally, I have collaborators around me. Karen Binns, which was there since the beginning, is my reference about look and gives me many choices. For the make up and the hair, I work with different teams, depending if I live in England or in the U.S. Photographs change all the time, but my clothes are always from Karen. It's a friend coming from Brooklyn (New York). She's a little mad! She lives in London but grew up in the ghetto. She attends photo shoots and creates my looks.

B: Are you interested by French fashion?

T: I feel perfectly at ease in Paris, because I always liked that style was a full part of people's live, architecture, and things' shape. There's a strongly developed visual meaning in France, which collapses in other countries, where everyone looks for "cheap" rather than for "beautiful". Andrea Walker, who designed my pants-combo during my 1996 tour, lives in Paris, despite being African-American. For this tour, Andrea co-worked with German Suzan Deeken. She's one of the greatest designers for Ghost (clothes company from London). What she made with me, was like Victorian-era sent into the alphan century. These kind of paradoxes can be seen in my clothes.

B: Let's talk about your new album... Why release "To Venus and Back" with that format?

T: At the start, the idea was one cd live and one cd of rare and unreleased tracks. In the end, it's a new album that goes with the live. Artistically, this began to make sense because the live disc is a collection of songs throughout the years. These are the best performances of the last tour. There are bootlegs circulating, but they don't give a faithfull image of my music. Then I wanted to add B-sides, for all those who had troubles trying to find rare tracks, but new songs came. I added them and the engineers told me: "These songs have a particular sound; if you mix them with b-sides, it's like mixing characters from two different movies." It was quite hazardous.

B: Your label sued an internet site because they broadcast "Spark" on the web, but did approve recently of the free downloading of "Bliss." Provided your tour with Alanis Morissette is sponsored by MP3.com, a free download site, how do you explain this change of position?

T: It wasn't a personal decision. What's important about mp3, is the way everything is ruled. If you look at internet like a juke-box, it's not stealing the work of an artist. "Bliss" is also broadcasted on the radio, you can listen to it in your car, it's not very different from an internet broadcast. But it's very different and I'm almost shocked when you can download a whole album. It's a lack of respect towards the artist.

B: It's a kind of a violation.

T: Yes, because art has a value we hold in our hearts. Sometimes, someone in the venue I play brings a wine bottle from her cellar, and I take it with pleasure. But if I like the wine, I'd like to buy some to promote the production. The danger of mp3, is that some imagine that music should be free. I think it shouldn't be free unless everything is free. It's funny the way people get happy with the idea of free things, as long as they don't belong to them. Value is an important word to me. I can also demonstrate that by buying a book, we help the writer to continue writing. There should be a debate over what should be allowed or not on the internet.

B: Some of your songs are just you and the piano. What do you feel when you have to play them live, without any net? Stress?

T: Sometimes... I am with a band and there is in the concerts the "secret moment" [when she plays piano alone] When the other musicians go out, I am very concentrated. If I have to go alone on stage, as I used to do, I prepare myself in another way. For this tour we have approached the songs together. But when the piano and the singing appear alone, it's like being naked.

B: During some of the gigs, fans throw letters and flowers at you. Do you remember the most touching expression of a fan?

T: A lot of letters are disturbing. People tell me secrets nobody talks about. I'm frightened when I read some experiences, because they happend years ago. One letter told the story of a young woman who, when she was 7, has been raped by her father and brother. I get letters from people trying to heal a deep scar which changed their lives forever.

B: You talked about rape. The song "Me and a Gun" still appears at concerts. Isn't it feeding a bad memory of your childhood?

T: I don't play it that often anymore because I changed, thanks to her. On one period, I felt the need to play it every night. I changed because I faced the demon. I went through this test and the butterfly freed himself. But you don't come over such a nightmare without hard work.

B: You gave birth to RAINN and you still agree to talk about rape. Was it difficult for you to trust a man until the moment you got married?

T: [pause] It's not that simple. Sometimes, there are classical signs by the victims, but it's not that clear. [very slowly] The different relationships I've had... I wouldn't be here if I hadn't known the men I dated. That too has to be worked on. You become a better partner. Then you meet someone who, thanks to his experiences, got better too.

B: Alanis Morissette told us how much "Little Earthquakes" moved her. Isn't it strange to be the support act for the one you influenced?

T: I'm not the opening act. It's a tour with two main singers.

B: But the public often thinks the one who plays last is the most important.

T: It's a little frustrating. It's quite a European idea, because of the many festivals. When you see your ticket, what do you read? Alanis and Tori. We have an openinig act every night, but we can't get on stage at the same time. It was my choice to play first, because of the piano. Once the balance has taken place, the piano cannot move anymore. She was very nice to understand that. Her management wanted us to switch position every night but that was ridiculous. We are both leading this tour. I won't be an opening act for anyone, now that I am where I am.

What do you think of Alanis on the human plane?

We've become friends. I knew her before and I know more about her now. Alanis is one of those rare people with whom I can imagine myself just passing time, or walking on the beach even after the end of the tour. That isn't something I can say about a lot of people. About very, very few... Maybe just of Maynard (James Keenan, singer) of TOOL and of Alanis. We are completely in phase. Our relationship is based on mutual respect. That's why I would never ask her to open for me or vice versa. That would be completely dishonorable.

The media can't stop talking about how women have dominated the music of the 90's.

How insulting to Janis Joplin, huh?

Do you think women have already proven themselves or that they still need festivals like Lilith Fair, write-ups in magazines and questions like the the one I'm in the middle of asking?

This isn't new. Let's just consider the business aspect: very few women have been signed by the record companies or put on the radio. When I arrived in 1991, it was really hard for me to get played. NIRVANA was just beginning to really get going. Grunge was the fashion. Being a singer, my strength was in the content, not in whether or not I was screaming. It took some time to break down the barriers of that hermetic [probably Tori's word, don't you think? --Stu] time. The industry works in cycles. In this moment, we are in the counterstrike against the grunge period. Three or four years after I got started, female singers began to find new opportunities. Before arriving at a 50-50 equilibrium, there was a period of 80% boys and 20% girls. The good news is that women have had more chances to affirm themselves, and not just in pop. There have always been a lot of women in pop, but never as many as far as songwriters go.

Out of personal curiosity... your name is Myra; why have it changed to Tori?

That's the name my parents gave me; it doesn't represent what I am. It was their concept, not mine.

What does Tori mean?

Clitoris.

The Interview With Steve Caton

Thanks to Stuart LaRosa for translating this for me!. I have it from a reliable source that what Steve actually said and what you read below are not exactly perfect. Some of it is off from what and how Steve said it. This is not to say the Steve interview is bad, only that how it reads does not exactly reveal how Steve would actually say it. This happens a lot in print. Just a minor warning!

THE MAN IN THE SHADOW

The distorted guitar in "Precious Things," the acoustic guitar in "Cornflake Girl," or the atmospheric guitar in "Spark" are all the work of Steve Caton. This 42-year-old guitarist has been writing, recording, and playing live with Tori Amos since her first group, Y KANT TORI READ. Born in California and influenced by Brian Eno, David Bowie and ROXY MUSIC, he brings so many different sounds to his musique that he calls his style... "non-guitaristic."

AN INTERVIEW WITH STEVE CATON (guitar)

How did you and Tori begin working together?

It was 14 years ago. I was a friend of Matt Sorum (later THE CULT, GUNS N' ROSES). We had known each other for a long time. He met Tori and played with her in a piano bar, I think. They started rehearsing and were looking for a guitarist. Matt called me and we ended up founding this club group. I already had some of my own work and Tori helped out by tightening up the choruses. We were in each other's groups for a long time. Tori's was called Y KANT TORI READ. There's been some confusion BECAUSE that was also the name of her first album. Moreover, the album wasn't even entirely recorded by us. There was a lot of production--some thirty musicians. It was very different from what we had conceived in the clubs.

What has been your biggest contribution to Tori?

We've been playing together for so long that she knows exactly what I'm doing and vice versa. I would say that she leaves me 99% free to play how I want. There are so many parts where the guitars don't sound like guitars. Some people tell me: "I listened to this album you play on, but I never heard you!" And I tell them that I do appear on it, but that what I do is "non-guitaristic."

Are you ever frustrated by being in a group whose dominant instrument is the piano?

No, I really love what I do with Tori. I'm no amateur caught up in a frenzy of technique, nor am I the type that goes for an avalanche of notes. I'm interested in the texture of sounds.

Are you OK with the fact that people only talk about her?

That's typical of pop. It's like the quarterback of a football team. Without the work of the others, he can't do anything. Of course, it's always him who gets the honors. But when he takes a stand, it's also he who takes responsibility for whatever's coming.

What are your other projects?

I have Binge, a group with Matt, when he isn't with busy with THE CULT or when I'm free with respect to Tori. I'm the singer and principal writer. It's a serious project that takes up all our free time. We have a CD. Some songs are a bit dance influenced. We've been compared to a lot of groups, but I haven't really liked any of these comparisons. There's a tendency toward DEPECHE MODE and NINE INCH NAILS, but certain pieces are twelve years old and NIN didn't exist then. Certain sounds might remind you of Tori's albums. As for being a writer, I've had a contract with a subsidiary of Paramount Pictures for years. I write songs for films and TV shows.

According to Tori Amos's fan club, "A Dent In The Net Universe," (www.tori.by.net) BINGE's album can be ordered for 9,595 Francs by sending a check or money order to FEB Music, PO Box 57494 SHERMAN OAKS, CA, 91413-2494, USA. Any special fee that might exist for ordering abroad isn't specified.

Note from Mikewhy: The Dent is not Tori's fan club, but I am grateful they mentioned my site! You can now order the Binge album a different way. Check my Binge page for the latest details.

Go Back To Articles

Go Back To ToriNews

Please give me feedback, comments, or suggestions about The Dent. Email me (Mikewhy) at mikewhy@iglou.com